Connect with us

Movie Reviews

‘The Last Thing Mary Saw’ Review: A Poisonous Queer Period Piece

Published

on

The Last Thing Mary Saw

Gay or lesbian period pieces have almost become a trope at this point (looking at you, Ammonite) but how often do they cross into the horror genre? Edoardo Vitaletti’s debut film The Last Thing Mary Saw puts this relationship at the center of the hostile religious environment of 19th century America. 

Flirting with themes of the occult and maintaining a tense tone throughout, this film fits with other bleak, modern folk films like The Witch, The Nightingale, and Midsommar. The unapologetic relationship between the two leading women and the intense story stands out, but the film is also bogged down by a slow pace and a somewhat convoluted plot. 

The Last Thing Mary Saw Isabelle Fuhrman

Stefanie Scott and Isabelle Fuhrman in “The Last Thing Mary Saw” – Photo Credit: Shudder

The Last Thing Mary Saw begins with Mary, interrogated while blindfolded and bleeding from the eyes about her grandmother’s death and what happened during her funeral. She recounts the events leading up to that moment, of being romantically involved with the housemaid, Eleanor, and her family’s disgust and punishment of the couple. The family bickers and plots about the couple, at the same time they plan their own escape as an intruder invades their home. 

The Last Thing Mary Saw stars Stefanie Scott (Insidious: Chapter 3, Beautiful Boy) and Isabelle Fuhrman (Orphan, The Hunger Games, The Novice) as the forbidden lovers in Victorian America, and Rory Culkin (Lords of Chaos, Scream 4) as an unhinged intruder in their household. 

The three leads expertly convey the frustration of being in their circumstances, with Fuhrman standing out for acting almost wordlessly and Culkin bringing a nuanced, chaotic energy to the film. 

Rory Culkin The Last Thing Mary Saw

Rory Culkin in “The Last Thing Mary Saw” – Photo Credit: Shudder

While the slow-burn in this film was a bit too slow, the progression of the film is still enjoyable and the ending is a bloody, crazy affair. 

The relationship at the center is framed in a pretty unique way: you don’t see how the girls fell in love or any apprehension they may have, but instead only tender affection on both sides. The religious aspects of this could definitely be controversial, but work with the film’s themes and reality of the setting. 

The girls take pleasure in reading a storybook to each other, but by the film’s end, this book turns on them. The book also serves as chapter markers for the film itself, seemingly following cautionary folklore, like the Bible. 

In general, the film has an extremely caustic view of Christianity, as it was portrayed as completely unforgiving, dangerous and useless. Often it framed the religious movement, especially at this point in history, as a tool to ostracize people who did not fit into the norm, especially women and queer people. This could have very easily been a witch film, but I feel it is telling that it never makes the queer characters out to be witches. Instead of making the women into monstrous archetypes of witches which would further alienate them, the film chooses instead to show how “witches” really were at that time period: regular women who dared defy some aspect of Christianity, or were simply accused out of lust or bitterness.

In The Last Thing Mary Saw, Christianity is used as a tool for punishment to uphold heteronormative patriarchy. 

The Last Thing Mary Saw

Stefanie Scott and Isabelle Fuhrman in “The Last Thing Mary Saw” – Photo Credit: Shudder

While this movie throws in a lot of tantalizing and shocking elements, it struggles to pull them together in a fully realized way. Like many other folky horror movies, it saves most of the action for the end, which some people may not see as a problem. At the same time, some of the action in this film seems thrown out of left field and it was a struggle to sometimes grasp what was happening at specific moments with the plot. 

Framing the film in flashback was also an organization choice that didn’t feel necessary, although I can understand why it was chosen. When it came to the final moments of the film, it felt like it softened the impact of the last third of the film. 

Another minor problem with the film is the lackluster editing, especially the music and sound design which seemed to be afterthoughts in the production process. There were moments where I was thinking, the music should be rising here, or this shot should have been cut a few seconds ago. 

The Last Thing Mary Saw

Photo Credit: Shudder

On the other hand, the cinematography here was very good, but also kind of locked into a familiar folk horror look: bleak landscapes, minimalist houses, browns and grey washes. As far as having a film take almost entirely inside a house, the camera work was very good and was reminiscent of still life early 19th century paintings, which the director actually cited as an inspiration. The painting influence on the film definitely shows and works well here to make a quite beautiful film.

Those that are into the recent resurgence of slow-burn, folk horror movies will definitely find a lot to like in this queer period piece. Compelling performances by Fuhrman and Culkin captivate the screen along with the strange progression of events and sinister and surprising ending. Those who are not fans of that specific sub-genre will probably not find much to enjoy here, as it very much falls in the familiar trappings of other modern folk horror, such as a slow pace. 

The Last Thing Mary Saw premieres on Shudder Jan. 20. Check the trailer out below. 

Listen to the 'Eye On Horror Podcast'

Listen to the 'Eye On Horror Podcast'

Click to comment

You must be logged in to post a comment Login

Leave a Reply

Movie Reviews

Panic Fest 2024 Review: ‘Haunted Ulster Live’

Published

on

Everything old is new again.

On Halloween 1998, the local news of Northern Ireland decide to do a special live report from an allegedly haunted house in Belfast. Hosted by local personality Gerry Burns (Mark Claney) and popular children’s presenter Michelle Kelly (Aimee Richardson) they intend to look at the supernatural forces disturbing the current family living there. With legends and folklore abound, is there an actual spirit curse in the building or something far more insidious at work?

Presented as a series of found footage from a long forgotten broadcast, Haunted Ulster Live follows similar formats and premises as Ghostwatch and The WNUF Halloween Special with a news crew investigating the supernatural for big ratings only to get in over their heads. And while the plot has certainly been done before, director Dominic O’Neill’s 90’s set tale of local access horror manages to stand out on its own ghastly feet. The dynamic between Gerry and Michelle is most prominent, with him being an experienced broadcaster who thinks this production is beneath him and Michelle being fresh blood who is considerably annoyed at being presented as costumed eye candy. This builds as the events within and around the domicile becomes too much to ignore as anything less than the real deal.

The cast of characters is rounded out by the McKillen family who have been dealing with the haunting for some time and how it’s had an effect on them. Experts are brought in to help explain the situation including the paranormal investigator Robert (Dave Fleming) and the psychic Sarah (Antoinette Morelli) who bring their own perspectives and angles to the haunting. A long and colorful history is established about the house, with Robert discussing how it used to be the site of an ancient ceremonial stone, the center of leylines, and how it was possibly possessed by the ghost of a former owner named Mr. Newell. And local legends abound about a nefarious spirit named Blackfoot Jack that would leave trails of dark footprints in his wake. It’s a fun twist having multiple potential explanations for the site’s strange occurrences instead of one end-all be-all source. Especially as the events unfold and the investigators try to discover the truth.

At its 79 minute timelength, and the encompassing broadcast, it’s a bit of a slow burn as the characters and lore is established. Between some news interruptions and behind the scenes footage, the action is mostly focused on Gerry and Michelle and the build up to their actual encounters with forces beyond their comprehension. I will give kudos that it went places I didn’t expect, leading to a surprisingly poignant and spiritually horrifying third act.

So, while Haunted Ulster Live isn’t exactly trendsetting, it definitely follows in the footsteps of similar found footage and broadcast horror films to walk its own path. Making for an entertaining and compact piece of mockumentary. If you’re a fan of the sub-genres, Haunted Ulster Live is well worth a watch.

3 eyes out of 5
Listen to the 'Eye On Horror Podcast'

Listen to the 'Eye On Horror Podcast'

Continue Reading

Movie Reviews

Panic Fest 2024 Review: ‘Never Hike Alone 2’

Published

on

There are fewer icons more recognizable than the slasher. Freddy Krueger. Michael Myers. Victor Crowley. Notorious killers who always seem to come back for more no matter how many times they are slain or their franchises seemingly put to a final chapter or nightmare. And so it seems that even some legal disputes cannot stop one of the most memorable movie murderers of all: Jason Voorhees!

Following the events of the first Never Hike Alone, outdoorsman and YouTuber Kyle McLeod (Drew Leighty) has been hospitalized after his encounter with the long thought dead Jason Voorhees, saved by perhaps the hockey masked killer’s greatest adversary Tommy Jarvis (Thom Mathews) who now currently works as an EMT around Crystal Lake. Still haunted by Jason, Tommy Jarvis struggles to find a sense of stability and this latest encounter is pushing him to end the reign of Voorhees once and for all…

Never Hike Alone made a splash online as a well shot and thoughtful fan film continuation of the classic slasher franchise that was built up with the snowbound follow up Never Hike In The Snow and now climaxing with this direct sequel. It’s not only an incredible Friday The 13th love letter, but a well thought out and entertaining epilogue of sorts to the infamous ‘Tommy Jarvis Trilogy’ from within the franchise that encapsulated Friday The 13th Part IV: The Final Chapter, Friday The 13th Part V: A New Beginning, and Friday The 13th Part VI: Jason Lives. Even getting some of the original cast back as their characters to continue the tale! Thom Mathews being the most prominent as Tommy Jarvis, but with other series casting like Vincent Guastaferro returning as now Sheriff Rick Cologne and still having a bone to pick with Jarvis and the mess around Jason Voorhees. Even featuring some Friday The 13th alumni like Part III‘s Larry Zerner as the mayor of Crystal Lake!

On top of that, the movie delivers on kills and action. Taking turns that some of the previous fils never got the chance to deliver on. Most prominently, Jason Voorhees going on a rampage through Crystal Lake proper when he slices his way through a hospital! Creating a nice throughline of the mythology of Friday The 13th, Tommy Jarvis and the cast’s trauma, and Jason doing what he does best in the most cinematically gory ways possible.

The Never Hike Alone films from Womp Stomp Films and Vincente DiSanti are a testament to the fanbase of Friday The 13th and the still enduring popularity of those films and of Jason Voorhees. And while officially, no new movie in the franchise is on the horizon for the foreseeable future, at the very least there is some comfort knowing fans are willing to go to these lengths to fill the void.

Listen to the 'Eye On Horror Podcast'

Listen to the 'Eye On Horror Podcast'

Continue Reading

Movie Reviews

Panic Fest 2024 Review: ‘The Ceremony Is About To Begin’

Published

on

People will look for answers and belonging in the darkest places and the darkest people. The Osiris Collective is a commune predicated upon ancient Egyptian theology and was run by the mysterious Father Osiris. The group boasted dozens of members, each forgoing their old lives for one held in the Egyptian themed land owned by Osiris in Northern California. But the good times take a turn for the worst when in 2018, an upstart member of the collective named Anubis (Chad Westbrook Hinds) reports Osiris disappearing while mountain climbing and declaring himself the new leader. A schism ensued with many members leaving the cult under Anubis’ unhinged leadership. A documentary is being made by a young man named Keith (John Laird) whose fixation with The Osiris Collective stems from his girlfriend Maddy leaving him for the group several years ago. When Keith gets invited to document the commune by Anubis himself, he decides to investigate, only to get wrapped up in horrors he couldn’t even imagine…

The Ceremony Is About To Begin is the latest genre twisting horror film from Red Snow‘s Sean Nichols Lynch. This time tackling cultist horror along with a mockumentary style and the Egyptian mythology theme for the cherry on top. I was a big fan of Red Snow‘s subversiveness of the vampire romance sub-genre and was excited to see what this take would bring. While the movie has some interesting ideas and a decent tension between the meek Keith and the erratic Anubis, it just doesn’t exactly thread everything together in a succinct fashion.

The story begins with a true crime documentary style interviewing former members of The Osiris Collective and sets-up what led the cult to where it is now. This aspect of the storyline, especially Keith’s own personal interest in the cult, made it an interesting plotline. But aside from some clips later on, it doesn’t play as much a factor. The focus is largely on the dynamic between Anubis and Keith, which is toxic to put it lightly. Interestingly, Chad Westbrook Hinds and John Lairds are both credited as writers on The Ceremony Is About To Begin and definitely feel like they’re putting their all into these characters. Anubis is the very definition of a cult leader. Charismatic, philosophical, whimsical, and threateningly dangerous at the drop of a hat.

Yet strangely, the commune is deserted of all cult members. Creating a ghost town that only amps up the danger as Keith documents Anubis’ alleged utopia. A lot of the back and forth between them drags at times as they struggle for control and Anubis keeps continuing to convince Keith to stick around despite the threatening situation. This does lead to a pretty fun and bloody finale that fully leans into mummy horror.

Overall, despite meandering and having a bit of a slow pace, The ceremony Is About To Begin is a fairly entertaining cult, found footage, and mummy horror hybrid. If you want mummies, it delivers on mummies!

Listen to the 'Eye On Horror Podcast'

Listen to the 'Eye On Horror Podcast'

Continue Reading