Connect with us

Movie Reviews

‘The Last Thing Mary Saw’ Review: A Poisonous Queer Period Piece

Published

on

The Last Thing Mary Saw

Gay or lesbian period pieces have almost become a trope at this point (looking at you, Ammonite) but how often do they cross into the horror genre? Edoardo Vitaletti’s debut film The Last Thing Mary Saw puts this relationship at the center of the hostile religious environment of 19th century America. 

Flirting with themes of the occult and maintaining a tense tone throughout, this film fits with other bleak, modern folk films like The Witch, The Nightingale, and Midsommar. The unapologetic relationship between the two leading women and the intense story stands out, but the film is also bogged down by a slow pace and a somewhat convoluted plot. 

The Last Thing Mary Saw Isabelle Fuhrman

Stefanie Scott and Isabelle Fuhrman in “The Last Thing Mary Saw” – Photo Credit: Shudder

The Last Thing Mary Saw begins with Mary, interrogated while blindfolded and bleeding from the eyes about her grandmother’s death and what happened during her funeral. She recounts the events leading up to that moment, of being romantically involved with the housemaid, Eleanor, and her family’s disgust and punishment of the couple. The family bickers and plots about the couple, at the same time they plan their own escape as an intruder invades their home. 

The Last Thing Mary Saw stars Stefanie Scott (Insidious: Chapter 3, Beautiful Boy) and Isabelle Fuhrman (Orphan, The Hunger Games, The Novice) as the forbidden lovers in Victorian America, and Rory Culkin (Lords of Chaos, Scream 4) as an unhinged intruder in their household. 

The three leads expertly convey the frustration of being in their circumstances, with Fuhrman standing out for acting almost wordlessly and Culkin bringing a nuanced, chaotic energy to the film. 

Rory Culkin The Last Thing Mary Saw

Rory Culkin in “The Last Thing Mary Saw” – Photo Credit: Shudder

While the slow-burn in this film was a bit too slow, the progression of the film is still enjoyable and the ending is a bloody, crazy affair. 

The relationship at the center is framed in a pretty unique way: you don’t see how the girls fell in love or any apprehension they may have, but instead only tender affection on both sides. The religious aspects of this could definitely be controversial, but work with the film’s themes and reality of the setting. 

The girls take pleasure in reading a storybook to each other, but by the film’s end, this book turns on them. The book also serves as chapter markers for the film itself, seemingly following cautionary folklore, like the Bible. 

In general, the film has an extremely caustic view of Christianity, as it was portrayed as completely unforgiving, dangerous and useless. Often it framed the religious movement, especially at this point in history, as a tool to ostracize people who did not fit into the norm, especially women and queer people. This could have very easily been a witch film, but I feel it is telling that it never makes the queer characters out to be witches. Instead of making the women into monstrous archetypes of witches which would further alienate them, the film chooses instead to show how “witches” really were at that time period: regular women who dared defy some aspect of Christianity, or were simply accused out of lust or bitterness.

In The Last Thing Mary Saw, Christianity is used as a tool for punishment to uphold heteronormative patriarchy. 

The Last Thing Mary Saw

Stefanie Scott and Isabelle Fuhrman in “The Last Thing Mary Saw” – Photo Credit: Shudder

While this movie throws in a lot of tantalizing and shocking elements, it struggles to pull them together in a fully realized way. Like many other folky horror movies, it saves most of the action for the end, which some people may not see as a problem. At the same time, some of the action in this film seems thrown out of left field and it was a struggle to sometimes grasp what was happening at specific moments with the plot. 

Framing the film in flashback was also an organization choice that didn’t feel necessary, although I can understand why it was chosen. When it came to the final moments of the film, it felt like it softened the impact of the last third of the film. 

Another minor problem with the film is the lackluster editing, especially the music and sound design which seemed to be afterthoughts in the production process. There were moments where I was thinking, the music should be rising here, or this shot should have been cut a few seconds ago. 

The Last Thing Mary Saw

Photo Credit: Shudder

On the other hand, the cinematography here was very good, but also kind of locked into a familiar folk horror look: bleak landscapes, minimalist houses, browns and grey washes. As far as having a film take almost entirely inside a house, the camera work was very good and was reminiscent of still life early 19th century paintings, which the director actually cited as an inspiration. The painting influence on the film definitely shows and works well here to make a quite beautiful film.

Those that are into the recent resurgence of slow-burn, folk horror movies will definitely find a lot to like in this queer period piece. Compelling performances by Fuhrman and Culkin captivate the screen along with the strange progression of events and sinister and surprising ending. Those who are not fans of that specific sub-genre will probably not find much to enjoy here, as it very much falls in the familiar trappings of other modern folk horror, such as a slow pace. 

The Last Thing Mary Saw premieres on Shudder Jan. 20. Check the trailer out below. 

Listen to the 'Eye On Horror Podcast'

Listen to the 'Eye On Horror Podcast'

Click to comment

You must be logged in to post a comment Login

Leave a Reply

Movie Reviews

‘Skinwalkers: American Werewolves 2’ is Packed with Cryptid Tales [Movie Review]

Published

on

The Skinwalkers Werewolves

As a longtime werewolf enthusiast, I’m immediately drawn to anything featuring the word “werewolf”. Adding Skinwalkers into the mix? Now, you’ve truly captured my interest. Needless to say, I was thrilled to check out Small Town Monsters’ new documentary ‘Skinwalkers: American Werewolves 2’. Below is the synopsis:

“Across the four corners of the American Southwest, there is said to exist an ancient, supernatural evil that preys on the fear of its victims to gain greater power. Now, witnesses lift the veil on the most terrifying encounters with modern-day werewolves ever heard. These stories intertwine legends of upright canids with hellhounds, poltergeists, and even the mythical Skinwalker, promising true terror.”

The Skinwalkers: American Werewolves 2

Centered around shapeshifting and told through firsthand accounts from the Southwest, the film brims with chilling stories. (Note: iHorror has not independently verified any claims made in the film.) These narratives are the heart of the film’s entertainment value. Despite the mostly basic backdrops and transitions—notably lacking in special effects—the film maintains a steady pace, thanks largely to its focus on witness accounts.

While the documentary lacks concrete evidence to support the tales, it remains a captivating watch, especially for cryptid enthusiasts. Skeptics may not be converted, but the stories are intriguing.

After watching, am I convinced? Not entirely. Did it make me question my reality for a while? Absolutely. And isn’t that, after all, part of the fun?

‘Skinwalkers: American Werewolves 2’ is now available on VOD and Digital HD, with Blu-ray and DVD formats offered exclusively by Small Town Monsters.

Listen to the 'Eye On Horror Podcast'

Listen to the 'Eye On Horror Podcast'

Continue Reading

Movie Reviews

‘Slay’ is Wonderful, It’s Like if ‘From Dusk Till Dawn’ Met ‘Too Wong Foo’

Published

on

Slay Horror Movie

Before you dismiss Slay as a gimmick, we can tell you, it is. But it’s a damn good one. 

Four drag queens are mistakenly booked at a stereotypical biker bar in the desert where they have to combat bigots…and vampires. You read that right. Think, Too Wong Foo at the Titty Twister. Even if you don’t get those references, you will still have a good time.

Before you sashay away from this Tubi offering, here is why you shouldn’t. It’s surprisingly funny and manages to have a few scary moments along the way. It’s a midnight movie at its core and if those bookings were still a thing, Slay would probably have a successful run. 

The premise is simple, again, four drag queens played by Trinity the Tuck, Heidi N Closet, Crystal Methyd, and Cara Mell find themselves at a biker bar unaware that an alpha vampire is on the loose in the woods and has already bitten one of the townsfolk. The turned man makes his way to the old roadside saloon and begins turning the patrons into the undead right in the middle of the drag show. The queens, along with the local barflies, barricade themselves inside the bar and must defend themselves against the growing hoard outside.

“Slay”

The contrast between the denim and leather of the bikers, and the ball gowns and Swarovski crystals of the queens, is a sight gag I can appreciate. During the whole ordeal, none of the queens gets out of costume or sheds their drag personas except at the beginning. You forget they have other lives outside of their costumes.

All four of the leading ladies have had their time on Ru Paul’s Drag Race, But Slay is a lot more polished than a Drag Race acting challenge, and the leads elevate the camp when called for and tone it down when necessary. It is a well-balanced scale of comedy and horror.

Trinity the Tuck is primed with one-liners and double entendres which rat-a-tat from her mouth in gleeful succession. It’s not a cringy screenplay so every joke lands naturally with a required beat and professional timing.

There is one questionable joke made by a biker about who comes from Transylvania and it isn’t the highest brow but it doesn’t feel like punching down either. 

This might be the guiltiest pleasure of the year! It’s hilarious! 

Slay

Heidi N Closet is surprisingly well cast. It’s not that it’s surprising to see she can act, it’s just most people know her from Drag Race which doesn’t allow much range. Comically she’s on fire. In one scene she flips her hair behind her ear with a large baguette and then uses it as a weapon. The garlic, you see. It’s surprises like that that make this film so charming. 

The weaker actor here is Methyd who plays the dimwitted Bella Da Boys. Her creaky performance shaves a little off the rhythm but the other ladies take up her slack so it just becomes part of the chemistry.

Slay has some great special effects too. Despite using CGI blood, none of them take you out of the element. Some great work went into this movie from everyone involved.

The vampire rules are the same, stake through the heart, sunlight., etc. But what’s really neat is when the monsters are killed, they explode into a glitter-tinted dust cloud. 

It’s just as fun and silly as any Robert Rodriguez movie with probably a quarter of his budget. 

Director Jem Garrard keeps everything going at a rapid pace. She even throws in a dramatic twist which is played with as much seriousness as a soap opera, but it does pack a punch thanks to Trinity and Cara Melle. Oh, and they manage to squeeze in a message about hate during it all. Not a smooth transition but even the lumps in this film are made of buttercream.

Another twist, handled much more delicately is better thanks to veteran actor Neil Sandilands. I’m not going to spoil anything but let’s just say there are plenty of twists and, ahem, turns, which all add to the fun. 

Robyn Scott who plays barmaid Shiela is the standout comedian here. Her lines and gusto provide the most belly laughs. There should be a special award for her performance alone.

Slay is a delicious recipe with just the right amount of camp, gore, action, and originality. It’s the best horror comedy to come along in a while.

It’s no secret that independent films have to do a lot more for less. When they are this good it’s a reminder that big studios could be doing better.

With movies like Slay, every penny counts and just because the paychecks might be smaller it doesn’t mean the final product has to be. When the talent puts this much effort into a film, they deserve more, even if that recognition comes in the form of a review. Sometimes smaller movies like Slay have hearts too big for an IMAX screen.

And that’s the tea. 

You can stream Slay on Tubi right now.

Listen to the 'Eye On Horror Podcast'

Listen to the 'Eye On Horror Podcast'

Continue Reading

Movie Reviews

Review: Is There ‘No Way Up’ For This Shark Film?

Published

on

A flock of birds flies into the jet engine of a commercial airliner making it crash into the ocean with only a handful of survivors tasked with escaping the sinking plane while also enduring depleting oxygen and nasty sharks in No Way Up. But does this low-budget film rise above its shopworn monster trope or sink beneath the weight of its shoestring budget?

First, this film obviously isn’t on the level of another popular survival film, Society of the Snow, but surprisingly it isn’t Sharknado either. You can tell a lot of good direction went into making it and its stars are up for the task. The histrionics are kept at a bare minimum and unfortunately the same can be said about the suspense. That isn’t to say that No Way Up is a limp noodle, there is plenty here to keep you watching until the end, even if the last two minutes is offensive to your suspension of disbelief.

Let’s start with the good. No Way Up has plenty of good acting, especially from its lead Sophie McIntosh who plays Ava, a rich governor’s daughter with a heart of gold. Inside, she is struggling with the memory of her mother’s drowning and is never far from her overprotective older bodyguard Brandon played with nannyish diligence by Colm Meaney. McIntosh doesn’t reduce herself to the size of a B-movie, she is fully committed and gives a strong performance even if the material is trodden.

No Way Up

Another standout is Grace Nettle playing the 12-year-old Rosa who is traveling with her grandparents Hank (James Caroll Jordan) and Mardy (Phyllis Logan). Nettle doesn’t reduce her character to a delicate tween. She’s scared yes, but she also has some input and pretty good advice about surviving the situation.

Will Attenborough plays the unfiltered Kyle who I imagine was there for comic relief, but the young actor never successfully tempers his meanness with nuance, therefore he just comes across as a die-cut archetypical asshole inserted to complete the diverse ensemble.

Rounding out the cast is Manuel Pacific who plays Danilo the flight attendant who is the mark of Kyle’s homophobic aggressions. That whole interaction feels a bit outdated, but again Attenborough hasn’t fleshed out his character well enough to warrant any.

No Way Up

Continuing on with what is good in the film are the special effects. The plane crash scene, as they always are, is terrifying and realistic. Director Claudio Fäh has spared no expense in that department. You have seen it all before, but here, since you know they are crashing into the Pacific it’s more tense and when the plane hits the water you’ll wonder how they did it.

As for the sharks they are equally impressive. It’s hard to tell if they used live ones. There are no hints of CGI, no uncanny valley to speak of and the fish are genuinely threatening, although they don’t get the screentime you might be expecting.

Now with the bad. No Way Up is a great idea on paper, but the reality is something like this couldn’t happen in real life, especially with a jumbo jet crashing into the Pacific Ocean at such a fast speed. And even though the director has successfully made it seem like it could happen, there are so many factors that just don’t make sense when you think about it. Underwater air pressure is the first to come to mind.

It also lacks a cinematic polish. It has this straight-to-video feel, but the effects are so good that you can’t help but feel the cinematography, especially inside the plane should have been slightly elevated. But I’m being pedantic, No Way Up is a good time.

The ending doesn’t quite live up to the film’s potential and you will be questioning the limits of the human respiratory system, but again, that’s nitpicking.

Overall, No Way Up is a great way to spend an evening watching a survival horror movie with the family. There are some bloody images, but nothing too bad, and the shark scenes can be mildly intense. It is rated R on the low end.

No Way Up might not be the “next great shark” movie, but it is a thrilling drama that rises above the other chum so easily thrown into the waters of Hollywood thanks to the dedication of its stars and believable special effects.

No Way Up is now available to rent on digital platforms.

Listen to the 'Eye On Horror Podcast'

Listen to the 'Eye On Horror Podcast'

Continue Reading