Advertisement
Posthumous Review: Josh Tanner’s VHS Horror Doesn’t Know When to Stop

Posthumous Review: Josh Tanner’s VHS Horror Doesn’t Know When to Stop

Luna Gray
Written by Luna Gray

October 22, 2026

There’s a specific kind of grief that lives on old videotape. The colors bleed and the sound warbles and someone you lost keeps talking anyway. Posthumous understands that ache, and for most of its runtime it turns it into something unnerving. It’s a good horror film that occasionally mistakes doing more for doing better.

On her birthday Zoe (Sophie Lowe) stays at her father’s house and watches VHS birthday messages recorded by her mother Joanne (Kira-Che Heelan), who died before she could raise her. Tanner wrote the script with Jade van der Lei, and that tape soon leads somewhere it shouldn’t. I’ll leave the details for you to find.

Father and Daughter

What holds the film together is Zoe’s relationship with her father Neil (David Roberts). Their scenes feel lived in rather than built to set up the next scare. That matters because supernatural horror only works when we care who is standing in the dark. I cared about these two, and much of the dread comes from not wanting anything to happen to them.

The VHS imagery is where Posthumous really shines. The analog look belongs to the supernatural side of the story, so every warped frame feels like a door that might not stay shut. Those were the sequences I couldn’t look away from. Put the tapes and this family together and the film is at its most frightening.

One Ending Too Many

Then the third act arrives and keeps arriving. My problem isn’t that the film explains too much about its mystery. It reaches a strong emotional and narrative payoff and then keeps escalating past it. Each new development thins out what came before instead of building on it.

The problem comes from ambition rather than laziness, which makes it easier to forgive. Tanner clearly wants to send us out on a big finish, and I respect a debut that swings. But the story had already said what it needed to say, and I wish he had trusted that. The best horror in Posthumous was already on the tape. It just needed to know when to press stop.

Fan verdict and scores by iHorror

Luna Gray

Luna Gray is a trans horror critic, Senior Staff Writer at iHorror, author of No House Is Empty, and a lifelong horror obsessive with a soft spot for cult cinema.She specializes in cult, independent, folk, queer, international, streaming, and physical-media horror, along with horror history, haunted history, and folklore. She has seen too much and recommends most of it.Her reviews, interviews, features, and cultural criticism appear at iHorror. She also writes about horror history, folklore, cursed media, strange movies, and the things that refuse to stay buried at her Substack, The Void Writes Back. You can follow her on Facebook at Horror Made Me Like This.