Advertisement
A bloodied Jessica Chastain holds Arabella Olivia Clark's face in a still from Other Mommy

‘Other Mommy’ Box Office: $27.5M and a D+ CinemaScore

Vivian Thorne
Written by Vivian Thorne

October 11, 2026

$27.5 million from 3,365 theaters, and a D+ from the people who bought the tickets. Other Mommy won the weekend box office on studio estimates released Sunday, opening well past the roughly $20 million most forecasts had on it.

Universal put the film in theaters on October 9 for Blumhouse Atomic Monster, which produced it for about $19 million. Rob Savage directed from a screenplay by Nathan Elston, adapting Josh Malerman’s 2024 novel Incidents Around the House. Jessica Chastain plays Ursula and the thing wearing Ursula’s face; Arabella Olivia Clark plays eight-year-old Bela, who narrates the book. Malerman started the whole thing from something his brother’s child said at bedtime.

A D+ Puts It Beside ‘Hereditary’

CinemaScore polls opening-night crowds, and a D+ is the grade Hereditary carries. So does Megalopolis. Critics finished at 20% on Rotten Tomatoes, where they had already landed by Friday morning, and the audience score sat at 47%. None of it kept the film off the top of the chart.

Savage came out of lockdown horror, directing Host and Dashcam before Stephen King’s The Boogeyman handed him a wide release in 2023. Malerman has been adapted once before too: Bird Box, his 2014 novel, became the 2018 Netflix film with Sandra Bullock.

The theatrical poster for Other Mommy, the Universal and Blumhouse Atomic Monster adaptation of Josh Malerman's Incidents Around the House
The theatrical poster for Other Mommy, in theaters now from Universal.

Two-Thirds of the Crowd Was Under 35

The opening audience split evenly by gender and ran about two-thirds 18 to 34. “Everybody turned out for it,” Universal’s head of domestic distribution, Jim Orr, told the Associated Press. “It wasn’t just one particular demographic.” The film also went out in 50 overseas markets, for a global start of $45.2 million.

The Rest of the Top Five

Verity held second with $11.5 million, down 64% in its second weekend. Resident Evil took $8.4 million and pushed its domestic total to $138.5 million. Heart of the Beast made $7.1 million. Aaron Sorkin’s The Social Reckoning landed fifth with $5.5 million against a reported $30 million production cost.

Domestic ticket sales crossed $8 billion for the year on Friday, running more than 19% ahead of last year and about 8% behind 2019, per Rentrak. Final weekend figures land Monday.

Fan verdict and scores by iHorror

Vivian Thorne

Vivian Thorne is a horror writer drawn to psychological horror, dark literature, and unsettling storytelling. She covers films, books, reviews, and opinion pieces with a sharp eye for what makes horror linger long after the final frame fades.

iHorror is independently owned and reader-supported.
If you'd like to show your support 👇

Buy Us a Coffee