Ghostwatch, the 1992 BBC Halloween special staged as a live investigation of a haunted house in suburban London, is one of six 1990s titles Mike Flanagan has picked as the decade’s best horror. His note on it: “If you haven’t seen this, read nothing about it…a once in a lifetime experience that has proven far more influential on modern horror than anyone realizes.”
The six arrived on October 19 as the 1990s installment of the hallowatchlist, a 31-film run Tumblr is releasing across October with Flanagan curating. Each title comes with a few lines from him and a piece of commissioned fan art, and the films are going out in batches by decade. Tumblr launched the run with seven selections from the 1960s and 1970s.
welcome to our hallowatchlist, curated by mike flanagan! 31 of the acclaimed filmmaker’s all-time favorite horror films, unleashed throughout october. first up, seven selections from the ’60s and ’70s. scroll for musings from mike and fanart for each!
— tumblr (@tumblr) October 5, 2026
The Six Films
Two of them open the decade. The Exorcist III (1990) is, in Flanagan’s words, a “wildly underrated sequel” that “features incredible performances and one of the best scares in horror history.” Jacob’s Ladder (1990) he calls “mind-bending existential horror full of unforgettable imagery and a final act that has fueled decades of discussion.”

From 1992 he takes Candyman, “haunting, enduring, and one of the greatest examples of urban folklore I’ve ever seen,” alongside Ghostwatch.
The Two 1994 Picks
Both 1994 picks are films about horror turning on itself. Of Wes Craven’s New Nightmare, Flanagan writes: “Before Scream, Craven deconstructed the franchise he created to incredible effect.” He calls In the Mouth of Madness “John Carpenter’s apocalyptic masterpiece, and one of the most underrated films of the 1990s.” Carpenter has been talking about his own back catalogue this month as well, saying at the Academy Museum gala that the ending of The Thing hides a clue nobody has worked out.


Four of the six are films about stories that get loose from the people telling them, which is a thread running through a good deal of what Flanagan has made himself, including his eight-episode Carrie for Prime Video. Ghostwatch is the strangest thing on the list and the one that holds up best, because the format it borrowed is the format horror has been borrowing back ever since.











