Advertisement
Looky-loo Made Me Check My Windows. Its Creators Want You to Ask Why. (Nightmares Film Festival)

Looky-loo Made Me Check My Windows. Its Creators Want You to Ask Why. (Nightmares Film Festival)

Luna Gray
Written by Luna Gray

October 19, 2026

After I finished Looky-loo and its sequel, I walked through my house and checked every window. Not the doors. I lock those. I mean the windows I crack open on mild nights and forget about until morning. These films don’t leave you afraid of a man in a mask so much as suspicious of your own house.

I confessed this to director Jason Zink and writer Nolan Mihail when we sat down at Nightmares Film Festival in Columbus, where both films played as a double feature at the Gateway Film Center. They were delighted. “I love that,” came the response, and somebody at the table called it “a public safety announcement.”

Zink plays the faceless killer who documents his crimes as if he were making a movie. I watched Looky-loo: Part II over breakfast the morning of our interview, a terrible pairing. The first film is cold and alarmingly convincing, a voyeur’s diary that puts us too close to a man who treats other people’s lives as raw material. The sequel holds the formula steady until a third act I won’t go near here, and when something works this well there’s no reason to abandon it. Found footage lives or dies on whether we believe the people in front of the lens, and Part II‘s cast, including Julie Kashmanian, Kansas Bowling, Kali Malia Michaels and Jessa Flux, keeps that illusion intact. I loved both films.

The Key Under the Mat

looky-loo

The security failures got under my skin, so I asked about the research. Zink and Mihail explained that the killer has failed plenty of times in their imagined world, but he edits his own footage. We only see what he chooses to show. The mistakes and miscalculations are still there. He just doesn’t consider them worth including in his masterpiece.

Zink traced one of their inspirations to the Bling Ring, the burglars who reportedly found Paris Hilton’s key beneath her doormat and walked in. “If it works for Paris Hilton, that’s good enough for me, logically,” he said. He also admitted that his own house went unlocked for nine years, something that drove his wife nuts when she moved in. “We were a house of guys, and we didn’t have the same fears that women do.”

A home can feel perfectly safe to someone who has never had much reason to question it. For somebody else, the same unlocked door represents an entirely different possibility. The filmmakers have even heard from viewers who paused the movie to go retrieve keys they’d left outside. At least I waited until the credits rolled before checking my windows.

Bad Art on Purpose

looky-loo

Part II imagines the killer’s first movie is out in the world and that he reads what people say about it. Zink and Mihail took criticism of their actual first film and imagined how their character would respond. A recurring complaint on IMDb was that the original took too long to get to the killing. The sequel begins with considerably more violence because the killer has apparently taken the criticism seriously.

It also starts cracking his carefully constructed image. The filmmakers wanted audiences to recognize how petty and self-important he really is. He considers himself an extraordinary artist, somebody creating something worthy of admiration. The audience is increasingly allowed to see the pathetic man underneath that confidence.

The first film is ice. The second lets us feel him, tantrums and all.

His growth shows in the equipment. “In part one, he films everything up until the very last scene with a GoPro, so it never zooms,” the filmmakers explained. That final scene introduces the first real long-lens zoom. For Part II, they abandoned the GoPro for a Blackmagic 4K, a decision that made filming considerably more difficult but reflected the killer’s evolving ambitions.

The harder discipline was allowing him to make bad artistic decisions. They described writing conversations that audiences barely hear because the killer’s camera is too far away or positioned incorrectly. A more conventional filmmaker might move closer or provide a cleaner angle. Zink and Mihail deliberately resist that impulse because the footage supposedly belongs to someone who isn’t particularly good at making movies.

“He thinks he’s the greatest filmmaker there’s ever been. We know he’s not.”

That distinction is part of what makes these films work. The camera doesn’t feel like a storytelling device invented to show us everything we need to know. It feels like something an increasingly delusional man actually operated.

And the filmmakers aren’t finished with him.

Zink told me that making a horror trilogy has been an ambition since childhood.

“It’s been a dream of mine since I was a kid to make a horror trilogy.”

They conceived Looky-loo as a larger story, with each installment functioning as part of the killer’s progression. Their plans for a third film would escalate both his crimes and the sophistication of his filmmaking. There is no confirmed release date, but the intention has been there from the beginning.

The Sound of Something Real

While I was watching, my brother, a gore fan, heard the audio from another room and came into my office because he thought I was watching actual snuff.

That is not an easy thing to accomplish. Horror audiences have spent decades learning what fake violence looks and sounds like. We recognize the familiar rhythms of movie screams, the exaggerated impacts, and the carefully manufactured noises that tell us something terrible is happening. Looky-loo is convincing enough to briefly remove that distance.

When I told Zink and Mihail what happened, they immediately credited sound designer Casey Synesael.

“Like, we cannot make this work without Casey.”

The original film required an extraordinary amount of reconstruction. Much of the production audio was little more than scratch sound, leaving Synesael to recreate footsteps, environmental noises, fragments of dialogue, and countless other details that most viewers would never consciously notice.

“He almost recreated everything,” the filmmakers explained.

Some sequences were effectively silent films until the sound work was completed. It was Synesael’s first feature, and his background was in music rather than traditional feature-film sound design.

His work is a substantial part of why the found footage conceit never cracks. Eyes can be talked into a lot. Ears are harder to fool, and my brother’s believed it completely.

Why We Keep Watching

I ask every filmmaker what they want in an audience’s head as the credits roll. Mihail’s answer was especially revealing because he doesn’t want people walking out of Looky-loo celebrating its killer.

“I would be mortified to find someone who just thought, like, this is kick-ass,” he told me.

He contrasted that possibility with the way audiences enjoy characters like Freddy Krueger. Freddy is a monster who has become part of popular culture, somebody whose atrocities exist comfortably alongside action figures, T-shirts, and affectionate fandom. Mihail doesn’t want that relationship with the Looky-loo killer.

He wants audiences to recognize the fear that people, particularly women, already live with.

“I want people to understand, you know, I think especially other men, to understand that there’s a fear like that that’s present for a lot of people all the time because of the way that society is.”

Think back to that unlocked house of guys.

The first film’s anonymous victims serve that larger argument. Mihail brought up the concept of “the lesser dead,” associated with criminologist Steven Egger’s work on victims whose deaths receive less public attention because of their social standing.

“The existence of that scale is an indictment of humanity, I think,” Mihail said.

The anonymity of the women in the original Looky-loo was a deliberate choice, although not an entirely comfortable one for the filmmakers. The killer doesn’t care enough about his victims to tell their stories. He reduces them to characters in his own production, and the film forces us to experience them through that narrow and dehumanizing perspective.

Behind the scenes, however, those women have names and histories.

Mihail also discussed plans for a novelization that would take the form of an in-universe true-crime book rather than a traditional prose adaptation. It could provide a place for the characters’ histories and other details that the killer’s footage deliberately excludes.

That leads to the uncomfortable contradiction running through the entire conversation.

Mihail acknowledged that he and Zink are true-crime fans, but that fandom comes with complications.

“We both like true crime, but we acknowledge that it’s kind of gross, like having your favorite serial killer.”

He recalled hearing a podcast discussion in which the mention of a notorious murderer prompted an enthusiastic reaction. His objection was simple. There is nothing awesome about the real suffering behind those crimes.

“I love bloody movies. I don’t love blood in real life,” Zink added.

That distinction matters.

This year’s Nightmares Film Festival opened with a 4K restoration of Henry: Portrait of a Serial Killer, a film that has spent decades challenging audiences to examine their relationship with screen violence. We gather in dark rooms to watch men like these on purpose. We want to feel afraid. We sometimes want to be disgusted. We even enjoy the experience enough to come back for more.

Looky-loo is about a man who watches women, and about everyone who keeps watching him.

Zink and Mihail made two frightening movies without letting the fear cost anyone their dignity. Look at how rarely the genre manages that.

Then go check your windows.

Fan verdict and scores by iHorror

Luna Gray

Luna Gray is a trans horror critic, Senior Staff Writer at iHorror, author of No House Is Empty, and a lifelong horror obsessive with a soft spot for cult cinema.She specializes in cult, independent, folk, queer, international, streaming, and physical-media horror, along with horror history, haunted history, and folklore. She has seen too much and recommends most of it.Her reviews, interviews, features, and cultural criticism appear at iHorror. She also writes about horror history, folklore, cursed media, strange movies, and the things that refuse to stay buried at her Substack, The Void Writes Back. You can follow her on Facebook at Horror Made Me Like This.