Eddie Kaye Thomas
The dude who banged Stiffler’s mom in American Pie made his acting debut in Are You Afraid of the Dark‘s ” The Tale of the Curious Camera”. No pies or MILFs were harmed in this episode.
Melissa Joan Hart
Taking breaks in between Clarissa Explains it All, and before Sabrina the Teenage Witch, actress Melissa Joan Hart also hopped on the pre-teen horror series in “The Tale of the Frozen Ghost”.
Yep. The man who made the panties of women everywhere a little damper, and the guys man-crush hardcore, showed up in the episode “The Tale of Station 109.1”. I can’t recall, did he eat his cereal in that episode?
The arch nemesis of every damn Ghostface in the Scream franchise and The Craft hot mama Neve Campbell, starred in “The Tale of the Dangerous Soup”. Oh yea, you read that right. Soup. Not just any soup mind you; Green Pea soup. The most terrifying soup of them all.
Of course, this isn’t the entire list of well-known celebs to catch a role on Are You Afraid of the Dark. However, if you’re curious as to who else is on that roster, maybe now is a good time to revisit the series! As of now, we don’t have streaming anywhere in the United States (shakes fists). But, trusty YouTube and Splat can be our saviors for the time being.